Not every state in the union can be full of geniuses, right? At least that's what, at first glance, one might conclude after seeing the results of the "life'sDHA Index of Brain Health," an assessment that ranks all 50 states and the District of Columbia according to what its creators consider to be factors supporting brain health.

Washington, D.C., and nine brain-healthy states made the top 10 list. Here are the 10 lowest-ranking states: Indiana, North Dakota, South Carolina, Arkansas, Kentucky, Tennessee, Mississippi, Alabama, Oklahoma and, dead last, Louisiana.

The brain health evaluations, performed by researchers at Martek Biosciences Corp., were determined through an analysis of third-party data on the diet, physical health, mental health and social well being of the residents of each state.

Bing Search: Nutrition
View results for:

"The results show that the majority of the top-10-ranked states border or are near the Atlantic or Pacific oceans," says Michael Roizen, author and adviser to the Martek index. "One hypothesis is the accessibility of fish with its healthy fats and protein." Martek manufactures products fortified with DHA, a form of health-promoting omega-3 fat found naturally in certain fish.

Louisiana, the "least brainy" state, tied with Mississippi and Utah for the highest rate of involvement in religious and spiritual activities—something Martek considers a positive indicator for brain health. That measure determined 5 percent of each state's total brain health score. In addition to its low sales of fish and DHA-fortified foods, and moderately low fruit and vegetable consumption rates, the Bayou State, along with Kentucky, has the lowest breast-feeding rate in the nation. Breast-feeding naturally provides DHA omega-3, which Martek's report on the index cites as "important for brain development of infants."

Outside medical experts are hesitant to put too much stock in the rankings but still recognize their significance.

"If you spent your entire life in Louisiana and you move to New Hampshire, next thing you know are you going to be 'brain healthy'? Of course not," says James Giordano, director of the Center for Neurotechnology Studies at the Potomac Institute for Policy Studies in Arlington, Va.

But, he says, "I think what the researchers are saying is [high-ranked states] are the states where we find a number of different factors, in combination, that have the potential to contribute to a healthier brain."

David Perlmutter, a neurologist, points out that many of the states with the highest obesity rates are ranked among the least brain healthy. In the calculations that produced the index, a high obesity rate counted against a state.

"The fundamentals of Alzheimer's and Parkinson's are damaging inflammatory chemicals in the brain," he says. So being overweight or having diabetes, both of which contribute to inflammation in the body, sets a person up for these diseases, he says.

Interestingly, a closer look at how various states fare on the individual measures of brain health might weaken the authority of the rankings.

For example, Washington state, the third-best brain-healthy state in the country, also has one of the highest rates of deaths due to Alzheimer's disease. And somewhat bizarrely, Louisiana, the country's least brain-healthy state, had one of the lowest incidences of "poor mental health days," according to data compiled by Martek.

It's important to note that a state's score on each of the 21 brain health indicators was weighted against the national average. And on some metrics, like sleep, no state does well, Roizen says. So just because D.C. and Mississippi, for instance, received top marks on sleep, that doesn't mean people there get eight hours of shut-eye a night.

America's 10 Brainiest States

Find More on MSN Health & Fitness:

Courtesy of U.S. News & World Report

Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1-10 of 552
Tuesday, November 03, 2009 4:56:55 PM
It is surprising how many people take this screaming nonsense seriously ...
Tuesday, October 27, 2009 1:27:07 PM

aftermath623Thumbs up

 

Good post. Smile 

 

One failure of this article was to define what was meant by brain health. Another is it did not take into account the moving of the population and the effect that has on our nutrition as we change locations. It seemed centered on nutrition only and did not take into account the total picture. I agree the article like many today are paid for by 'interested parties' for the advertisement effect of certain finanacial groups. At least there is some motivation to discuss the topics or there would be no Internet. As badly as I hate commercials, they and our money pay for the Internet. It is a necessary evil since the government does not make money, it is not a producer. I make money at my job and pay taxes and some of the benefits come to me. But it is hard to draw a line where the benefit begins and ends.

 

The greatest failure of people, including my own, has been not to ask others or seek good advice before making a big decision.Sad Even little things can get you in trouble by not knowing what the experience of others is. Children often do not listen to parents or friends or listen to the wrong advice. Crying With the Internet we can listen to everybody and at least have some idea of what the right action must be by default.

 

I just wish this site would allow a vote talley and we wouldn't have to comment on each response, just vote up or down. Thumbs upThumbs downIt does have rich text and spell check which I like to use to better express myself. Yahoo does not, but it has the vote talley. It is hard to find the set up on some sites for comment but I am learning which have good ones.

 

We need more tolerance and less vitriole. We all need more ideas. Proverbs 11:14 'Where there is no counsel, the people fall; But in the multitude of counselors there is safety.'

 

I am a Christian and follow Jesus who was arguably the greatest teacher on earth. He asked questions and listened before teaching the better way of love and responsibiliy.

 

I enjoy helping others. Talk is cheap unless we actually are a positive influence on ourself and others. We must be motivated to do our best at our work and help others to see the benefit as well.

 

I think of articles like this one as a launching pad to discussions which lead to better thinking. I am sure the myopic views of the author would be revised after reading the comments of the posts. Don't you think the next article of the same person will be better written? I do. Thanks for the comment.

Wednesday, October 07, 2009 9:48:42 PM
Washington State only factors the elite parts of Seattle into all of their polls.  Go to the poorer parts of Tacoma and you will see plenty of people with low IQs. What about Spokane?  Great public relations people for Washington!
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 6:55:57 PM

looks like the brain dead states are the ones that gave us the last eight years of you-know-who, while the brainiest states wanted the academy award and nobel laureate!

 

Wednesday, October 07, 2009 6:22:48 PM
It funny that Indiana is one of the 10 lowest on a Brain Health Index.  Most people have no idea that the inventors of the television, hand-held calculator, and fax machine all lived in northeast Indiana.
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 1:41:57 PM
I'm sorry so many people took offense if their state was listed in the bottom ten, or chose to denigrate another state if theirs was in the top ten. Bottom line is that this study was taken from data collected by organizations like the CDC and was put together by a company that produces supplements with DHA. It was designed to support their products. That being said, Omega-3 fatty acids has been proven to promote brain health. The basic ideas of healthy eating, exercise, brain stimulation such as continued education, access to a variety of ideas, etc., all aid healthy active minds. As with any study, we can take the information gathered, whether from direct observation or through third-party sources, and make general assumptions. There are ANYWAYS exceptions and one can use this information as a guideline. However, I found that many responding to this article are using this forum to vent their own frustrated views and take this opportunity to bash someone elses. But please read the article and understand the study was created to support a reason to buy their product. It brings up some good point about health and education, but it was designed to sell their product. Please do not use it to insult each other and drive a wedge between ourselves when we need to pull together in these tough times. Remember, we are the United States of America, and our differences is our strength.
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 1:28:23 PM
According to this article, they are basing their information on the amount of seafood purchased. Well, in the Gulf states, most people CATCH their seafood and eat it fresh, not processed or packaged in a store. Whoever did this 'research' certainly didn't do it very well. I'm guessing they have never even visited the Gulf Coast. BTW - Washington DC is a state? When was THAT ratified???
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 1:18:45 PM
@ 122 - What does your Govener being from Canada have to do with anything? Arnold is from Ah-stria.
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 1:15:47 PM
Alas some one knows the story!
Wednesday, October 07, 2009 1:14:58 PM

Wow, Flip25. That's a big jump from this article talking about brain health (not intelligence) to you're interpretation of it saying "Republican = stupid". Please re-read the article and let us know what you think.

(Mind you I was not impressed with the science of the article but I am suprised at your response.)

1-10 of 552
To add a comment, pleasesign in

Popular Slide Shows

  • AHDH Foods to Eat & Avoid // (© White Rock/DAJ/Getty Images)
  • Guys: Your Best Body in One Hour // (© Images courtesy of Men's Health)
nutrition videos
4 free tools for fitness//© MSN Health & FitnessWeight Loss CalculatorsCustomized Workouts The Fit ZoneLose 10 Pounds
Train by Type//© MSN Health & Fitness
find a nutritionist

Powered by Bing

MSN Health & Fitness does not provide medical or any other health care advice, diagnosis or treatment.



IMA Winner 2009