23Next >

Dani was 7 years old when Florida police finally came to investigate allegations of child abuse at her house. Weighing just 46 pounds, she had spent most of her young life curled up alone in her room, and was never allowed outdoors—even to go to school or see a doctor. The neglect was so severe, one expert says, that she would have been better off if she had been raised by animals.

Her story—including her adoption by a remarkable couple and her astonishing steps towards recovery—was featured recently on "The Oprah Winfrey Show," after her case was first exposed in a poignant multimedia story in the St. Petersburg Times. Bruce Perry, M.D., Ph.D., was the featured guest on the program. He has evaluated Dani and is consulting on her treatment—and has also seen about 150 similar cases.

Chaos, abuse and neglect

When police found her in a small, Plant City, Florida rental house, Dani was naked except for a heavy diaper. The stench was so strong that the officers expected to find a dead body.

Instead, they discovered a feral child: A girl so profoundly neglected that she had never learned to eat solid food, speak, or even understand language. Dani wasn't toilet-trained, and although she could walk, her gait was crab-like and uneven: She skittered on her toes.

Seemingly oblivious to the filth around her, Dani's mentally impaired mother told the officers, "I'm doing the best I can."

Although such extreme stories are rare, child neglect can be as harmful as abuse, and is sadly very common. More than two-thirds of the 905,000 confirmed cases of child maltreatment reported to the National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System in 2006 involved neglect.

A feral child

"Feral" isn't a diagnosis, of course. But the term usually refers to a child raised by animals, like Romulus, the legendary founder of Rome who was said to have been reared by a she-wolf. In another case Perry consulted on, a Russian girl was "raised" by a pack of stray dogs until she was 8. She ran around on all fours and barked and imitated a whole range of other canine behaviors.

More recently, the term has been expanded to include children whose human care and contact was extremely limited.

Perry says low intelligence is common among parents who severely neglect their kids. "Most of the neglect cases are because there's an impaired, overwhelmed caregiver," he says. The most famous such case is that of "Genie"—a heartbreaking story of a Californian child who for 12 years was rarely exposed to speech and was restrained on a child potty. Researchers attempted to teach her language, but sadly discovered that without early exposure, some human capacities seem to be unable to be developed.

"Honestly, children raised by animals can be more healthy than children who are profoundly neglected like this," says Perry, "They actually had some form of socialization and interaction. It wasn't human, but it was touch, it was communication, there's reciprocity to it, so the few cases there are of true feral children, their outcome is better."

Although there were cats and dogs in her mother's house, Dani did not appear to have had that much contact with them.

23Next >
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1-10 of 111
Sunday, August 30, 2009 11:25:57 AM

This is so sad! Are social workers the ones that help children like these? I just can't believe that something so heatbreaking like this could happen. And that some of these damges can't be reversed? It makes me really really sad.

 

Oh and American dad, it's embedded into the American mind to put ourselves first and not think of the "greater good", ever read John Locke?

Friday, March 20, 2009 1:18:15 PM
Sadmy god it is so very hard to imagine this us happening to our neighbors children and we don't even know don't children have enough to fear with physical abuse sexual abuse and emotional neglect i have even become to understand the increase in drug abuse often is a result of these abuses .god bless our children and hopefully each one of us will try and step up keep our eyes,doors and hearts open
Friday, March 20, 2009 12:55:37 PM
Isn't New Jersey often referred to as the toilet of the United States? Or outhouse or something similiar....
Friday, March 20, 2009 12:55:34 PM
Oh My god! That is so sad! Not to mention disgusting! I want to cry  and throw-up at the same time. The world should really open their eyes. I really think the world is something different then it used to be. This  story is inhuman-like. I think the mother should be charged with child abuse, I really do. She should be put in a mental home or something. I want to help this child some how. I think we should start something that donates money to children in this situation. SickCrying Thank you for reading this. I hope someone is inspired to start something like this. I really hope this girl is getting better.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009 4:48:19 PM
Well said American Dad. I will chip in on the ticket. People want to bash this country should leave.
Monday, March 09, 2009 8:09:06 PM
I may be self centered but I do believe, I live in the greatest country on this planet.  I will admit that theire are bad people in this country, who bring shame and dishonor by ther actions and should be punished to the fullest extent of the law. But America is still the greatest country in the world and if you don't agree I'am sure there are many people who would gladly purchase Beetzart a one way ticket to anywhere they would like to go.!!!!!!! 
Monday, March 09, 2009 7:51:19 PM
not quite sure how this discussion turned towards greatest country on earth. I thought it was about neglected children. Someone said that we are a country of under educated people. He is correct in that statement. We are not alone on the planet in that regard. I have lived and worked abroad, Europe, S. America and Mexico. All over the western USA. It occurs to me that a country greatness is measured by how the other people in the world view that country. Are we the most powerful and influential country in the would? Perhaps. Does that make us great? In my opinion, no it does not. I may be wrong, but I believe we have the highest murder rate on the planet. A direct reflection of the amount of under educated people in this country. Child neglect falls into the same category. Educated people, as a rule do not behave in a manner such as this. There will without a doubt be exceptions to that rule. we shouldn't play head games with ourselves, we have a long way to go. 
Monday, March 09, 2009 6:56:37 PM
SadChild Abuse is disgusting and whoever did these horrible things to their own children are guilty and ,shameful to society and themselves, they are not punished enough the system ,sets them free and lets them get out back into society and then they have more kids it's all a sick and vicious cyle and it makes my stomach turn just thinking about it.
Monday, March 09, 2009 6:34:13 PM
I am amazed at what William Lierow said at the end of the article about how he didn't mind getting less attention from his parents because Dani needs it more. I commend him and his parents for what they are doing and I hope there are many more families in this world that can do such commendable things. Kudos, Lierow Family. Kudos.
Monday, March 09, 2009 6:25:56 PM
Unconscionable, but with mental impairment anything can happen.  Can't understand why no one noticed for 7 years.
1-10 of 111
To add a comment, pleasesign in

popular slide show on msn health & fitness
  • AHDH Foods to Eat & Avoid // (© White Rock/DAJ/Getty Images)
  • Guys: Your Best Body in One Hour // (© Images courtesy of Men's Health)
  • The Greatest Abs Workout Ever // (© Images Courtesy of Men's Health)
  • Fight Cholesterol With These Foods // avacado
videos © MSN Health & Fitness

MSN Health & Fitness does not provide medical or any other health care advice, diagnosis or treatment.



IMA Winner 2009