Second Opinions//Fresh perspectives on health news

rss RSS feed

New York fast-food patrons by the numbers

Posted by joanne at health on Friday, November 20, 2009 3:32 PM

About 18 months ago, New York City began requiring chain restaurants to post the number of calories in their food items on the menu board, near the price. The thinking was that the numbers would prompt healthier choices, and several cities and states joined the effort.

Two surveys about New Yorkers show striking results. Independent researchers, led by Brian Elbel, an assistant professor of medicine and health policy at New York University School of Medicine, concluded the law had no effect on the number of calories consumed in lower-income, minority neighborhoods, according to The New York Times.

The city revealed its findings at the annual meeting of The Obesity Society: City dwellers ordered items with fewer calories at four chains—Au Bon Pain, KFC, McDonald’s and Starbucks. The calorie drops were 152 at hamburger chains, 73 at sandwich chains and 23 at coffee shops.

In other words, not much changed; the thousands of New Yorkers surveyed apparently didn't care enough to fib about embracing a newfound caloric creed.

The NYU study, reported in Health Affairs, found that “27.7 percent who saw calorie labeling in New York said the information influenced their choices.” Yet, “We did not detect a change in calories purchased.”

The city’s health department survey found that in most chains, diners’ orders hardly changed the number of calories they consumed, but the calorie numbers in coffee shops dropped nearly 10 percent—56 percent of the patrons noticed the information, and 15 percent took the numbers to heart, for an average drop of 106 calories, even though many said they did not notice the information.

Do you want a pie chart with that? Just gestimates.

Conclusions:

     • New York City was not “expecting miracles” said Dr. Lynn Silver, an assistant commissioner in the city’s Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. “Dietary changes come slowly.”

     • The NYU researchers noted that obesity rates tend to be higher in lower-income and minority neighborhoods, and, “This is where we would have liked to see an impact most,” Dr. Elbel said. They recommend more research.

     • Most New Yorkers seem unmoved.

     • Most cynically: Why spend all that money—passing the law, redoing the menu boards, monitoring compliance and conducting surveys, writing about and presenting the results—for this?

 

Research says it is a feel-good move for everybody.

Posted by joanne at health on Friday, November 13, 2009 2:17 PM

Everybody knows all about exercise— the who, what, when, where and why—thanks to the public education campaigns of the last 14 years.

Well, only one-third of Americans absorbed the facts, according to Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. Two-thirds of Americans have been bypassed by the “highly generalized, saturating effect of media in the current environment,” researchers wrote. “Through varied sources, many are bombarded with multiple physical activity and general health promotion ‘recommendations’ that may be challenging to differentiate.”

That is just one of many news bits about exercise. We’re here to be saturated with “recommendations” so you won’t have to. Here are the latest facts about exercise:

A connection with nature makes us healthier.

Posted by joanne at health on Thursday, November 5, 2009 9:40 AM

The campy ’60s sitcom “Green Acres” was brilliant television imitating life: “Keep Manhattan, just give me that countryside.” Even for those who “get allergic smelling hay,” a connection with the natural world not only promotes better physical health, but leads to much better mental health than people who claim “New York is where I’d rather stay.”

A study in the Netherlands found that green space had a huge impact on mental health, and a study in Tokyo concluded that senior citizens who lived near green spaces where they could walk lived longer than their concrete-bound peers. Both studies were reported in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community.

Players have to really want it to curve.

Posted by joanne at health on Friday, October 30, 2009 2:28 PM

A troubling controversy has been stirred up again, threatening to spoil the World Series, showcase of Major League Baseball—a curveball doesn’t curve. It only looks that way because of a batter’s vision and perception.

Zhong-Lin Lu, a neurologist at USC, is the latest participant in the fray, saying that the ball hardly moves at all … but the batter perceives it as dropping  precipitously. Lu is a specialist in visual motion and perception.

Can 1976 repeat itself?

Posted by Theresa at Health.com on Tuesday, October 27, 2009 10:05 AM

In 1976, I was loving my striped bell-bottoms, groovy grown-up platforms (inherited from an older cousin—sweet!), the Bicentennial, and, um, swine flu.

 

I  know. Who could love the disease outbreak that wasn’t, generally considered a public-health fiasco? (You know, 30 to 40 million people vaccinated, no real flu in sight, and some dangerous vaccine side effects.)

 

Well, I did. I loved swine flu. Being 10 years old, I really didn’t have the slightest clue what was going on, and I visualized something vaguely pig-related when the topic came up. (Other news events of the time were similarly fuzzy; for example, Watergate had a Niagara Falls-ish look in my mind.)

1 of 29
twitter

Stay connected with MSN Health & Fitness on Twitter.

  • @MSNFitness

    Get news, information and advice on weight loss, nutrition and fitness.

  • @MSNHealth

    Breaking news, expert commentary and advice from the MSN Health & Fitness editors and other trusted sources.

about our bloggers

Jeri Condit is the senior editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Susannah Detlef is the Diet & Fitness editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Joanne Garrett is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Jessica Gartner is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness. She focuses on diseases and conditions.

David Hill is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Erik Johnston is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Amanda MacMillian is a science writer, fitness blogger, and senior associate editor at Health.com.

Theresa Tamkins is a news editor at Health.com.

MSN Health & Fitness does not provide medical or any other health care advice, diagnosis or treatment.



IMA Winner 2009