Second Opinions//Fresh perspectives on health news

Head Injuries Can Be Fatal, Even Without Immediate Symptoms

Natasha Richardson's death raises awareness of 'silent' trauma.

Posted by Coeli Carr on Wednesday, March 18, 2009 8:16 AM

Natasha Richardson (© Lucas Jackson/Reuters)

After a serious accident, victims often experience overt pain or immobility that leads them to seek immediate medical attention. But what if you injure your head and feel okay afterward? What should you do?

Actress Natasha Richardson, who was critically injured Monday after she fell during a private skiing lesson, reportedly did not show any apparent sign of injury, and she even walked after the incident. It wasn't until about an hour later that she reportedly complained of an extreme headache and was taken to a hospital. (UPDATE 5:16 PM: Natasha Richardson has died from the brain injury she sustained during a skiing accident. Our thoughts are with her family.) 

When you experience serious trauma to your head, you can be at risk, even if you feel fine and have no symptoms, says James J. McCarthy, M.D., assistant professor of emergency medicine at University of Texas Medical School at Houston.

"You've got confined space inside the skull, and blood from the injured blood vessels flows into the same space that the brain occupies," says McCarthy. "This growing clot of blood starts taking up more and more space, and puts pressure on and decreases the flow of oxygen to the brain." The brain can literally be squeezed to death, he says.

McCarthy says you may not have symptoms until you get a headache, which can be a sign of ongoing hemorrhage or bleeding around the brain. "This pressure [that's] built up makes the head hurt," he says. However, you can be free of symptoms for some time. McCarthy has seen people with head injuries who came to the hospital four or five days after their initial incident. In those cases, the clot inside the skull grew slowly, and pressure on the brain built up gradually.

If the injury to a blood vessel or vessels is small and your body's blood-clotting ability is normal, the bleeding may stop, says McCarthy. This would likely prevent a larger clot from forming, and pressure from building up. For more serious bleeding, surgery is often required to alleviate pressure on the brain, he says. People who are on blood thinning medication, such as Plavix, are also more at risk, because it's more difficult to stop the bleeding resulting from the trauma.

After head trauma, when do you need to seek medical care?

McCarthy advises getting evaluated at a hospital, if you become unconscious even briefly as a result of a head injury and even if you feel fine afterward. "Going unconscious raises your risk significantly," he says. If you feel fine, then watch for symptoms (or have a companion watch for signs), such as headaches, weakness or balance problems. If you experience these symptoms, seek medical attention immediately. 

You also need to be medically evaluated if you experience nausea or vomiting, says Jeff Kalina, M.D., associate medical director of emergency medicine at The Methodist Hospital in Houston. Pressure on the brain stimulates the vomit reflex, he says. And while a torn artery inside the head will cause the blood clot to form quickly, says Kalina, injuries to smaller blood vessels mean the clot may take longer to create pressure on the brain, potentially leaving the person symptom-free for a longer time. 

People older than 65 also may not show symptoms for a length of time, says Kalina. With these conditions, the brain is likely to have atrophied somewhat, which means less space is taken up in the skull. It therefore takes a longer time for collected blood to exert pressure around the brain, he says.

To help protect your head from trauma, wear a helmet when participating in sports, or when you're exposed to traffic while riding a bicycle, says McCarthy. Reports noted that Natasha Richardson was not wearing a helmet during her accident.

"The likelihood of a serious problem is very small if, after a head trauma, you've got no external signs of injury and you feel okay," says McCarthy. "But your risk is never zero."

Search for more information on head trauma.

Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1-10 of 244
Tuesday, March 24, 2009 3:02:10 PM
This is so sad
Friday, March 20, 2009 6:14:19 AM
As a Canadian who has gone to the ER with a head injury I can tell you that they IMMEDIATELY take you in for examination and CT scan if there's the SLIGHTEST possibility of head trauma. So stop being so presumptuous!
Friday, March 20, 2009 5:37:00 AM
Tdisk,

Try again...if a person is not visibly dying on the spot, multiple hour waits in an ER are extremely common in the US.  Don't give me the socialized medicine is bad argument, because an ER is the one place that anyone who enters is required to be treated.  If there is a wait there is a wait, regardless of anything but seriousness of the injury.  Same deal in Canada.  BTW, you see a doctor on average, more quickly in Canada, because people with less serious problems go to their physician, while in the US, those without insurance tend to let problems sit hoping they won't need to pay, until it bvecomes an emergency.

Thursday, March 19, 2009 8:38:30 PM
Was the person put on a "waiting list" by the Canadian socialized medicine so that she did not get timely treatment for four hours by a properly skilled professional?  This would not have happened in the USA.
Thursday, March 19, 2009 10:58:27 AM

It is sad and tragic any time there is the loss of a loved one, and especially so unexpectedly.  I wonder, Ms. Carr, why our thoughts AND PRAYERS cannot be with the family?  Mine certainly are.

Thursday, March 19, 2009 10:45:18 AM
Oh my gosh, after reading all these, I had to comment.  I rolled my Jeep 2 years ago and was HELP flighted to the ER.  Long story made short, even after vomited, passing out, and losing all bodily functions, they took me a little more serious.  My head hurt so bad, I couldn't stand it and then when a nurse finally noticed that every time they turned me to the left, I blacked out, they decided to do the scans.  They sent me home with a bunch of oxcontins and never ever even told me I had a concussion, or what to do about it.  I went home, fell asleep, and it was only when my daughter who is a nurse called, and younger kids told her what happened and I was asleep, did my daughter tell them to wake me up and not let me sleep.  I still get dizzy from time to time, and am worried to death that I might die someday from a blood clot!
Thursday, March 19, 2009 7:02:06 AM
I too had a subdural hematoma about 3 years ago.  The most important advice I can offer is find a qualified doctor when you have a suspected brain injury.  I went through hell for 3 months before being properly diagnosed.  All the doctors I was seeing would do was give me stronger and stronger pain pills.  I was alternating between 2 Vicodins and 2 Oxycotins every 2 hours and still in extreme pain and spontaniously vomiting.  I finally got in to Loyola University and within 2 hours was in intensive care.  Two holes in my head relieved the pressure and pain.  I still have a little memory loss  but am 95% now.  Thank you Dr. Shea!!!!    Please everyone, if you have any doubts, see a specialist!!!
Thursday, March 19, 2009 3:31:28 AM

The story of Natasha touched me, I also had a head injury that the ER staff didn't consider serious.  I had a good size contusion on the back of my head, and I actually did exhibit signs of brain injury. But even with that, the ER staff told me to lay down and shut up for an x-ray, because I was becoming very agitated with pain.  It is the last thing I remember, grabbing my head in both hands, in pain before throwing up, THAT is the sign that they actually saw, and sent me to a CAT scan and on to emergency brain surgery.  I also had a subdural hematoma, and my brain was torn in 3 places.  People need to be so watchful when someone hits their head.  I ALWAYS check my kids pupils and ask them questions.  I think that alot of stories will come out because of poor Natasha, but maybe someone will be saved down the line.  My condolences to her husband, children and family. 

Wednesday, March 18, 2009 6:46:55 PM
I am so sorry for your loss.  Your article states to seek medical assistance.  In my case, I went to the emergency room and they checked me over and sent me home.  They did not  do a cat scan.  They sent me home.  It was later discovered that I had a subdural hematoma.  I was a lucky person.  I had brain surgery to drain the bleed, no thanks to the ER staff who could have sent me home to die. 
#10
Wednesday, March 18, 2009 5:54:58 PM

For those who do not realize how fragile the brain is, and how a small item can effect you whole life. Place a single kernel of corn in your shoe and see what the results are. A small bleed 1/100th. of of a kernel can kill you. It roulette. You are in Vagas everytime receive a good thump on you head. Even when you show no signs of impact the big pile of Jell-O in you cranium with a thousand of miles blood vessels. Well what do you think the chances are something might go pop. Then when you say just go in and fix it. Many hospitals do not have a neuro surgeons on staff, and you needed him or her minutes  after the impact. It's not likely you will have one handy. The same drug that will dissolve the blood clot will unplug the original leak that caused the main problem.

  Wear a helmet when you get into an active sport.

1-10 of 244
To add a comment, pleasesign in
twitter

Stay connected with MSN Health & Fitness on Twitter.

  • @MSNFitness

    Get news, information and advice on weight loss, nutrition and fitness.

  • @MSNHealth

    Breaking news, expert commentary and advice from the MSN Health & Fitness editors and other trusted sources.

about our bloggers

Jeri Condit is the senior editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Susannah Detlef is the Diet & Fitness editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Joanne Garrett is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Jessica Gartner is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness. She focuses on diseases and conditions.

David Hill is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Erik Johnston is an editor at MSN Health & Fitness.

Amanda MacMillian is a science writer, fitness blogger, and senior associate editor at Health.com.

Theresa Tamkins is a news editor at Health.com.

MSN Health & Fitness does not provide medical or any other health care advice, diagnosis or treatment.



IMA Winner 2009